Forum Topics

Double standards - one rule for them and another for us

The Campaign Against AntiSemitism has just released a statement. This is part of it:There was a planned Walk Together between midday and 2.00 pm in London tomorrow in which there has been enormous interest. There are Jewish communities whose rabbis have given dispensation to their congregants to walk for hours on Shabbat in order to come to central London. Such is the depth of feeling among British Jews about the weekly marches, the record-breaking levels of antisemitism, and the repeated police failures.Tomorrow’s march by the Palestine Solidarity Campaign meanders for two-and-a-half miles, from Parliament Square to Reformer’s Tree in Hyde Park. WHEN WE ORGANISED OUR PEACEFUL MARCH AGAINST ANTISEMITISM A FEW MONTHS AGO WE WERE TOLD THAT THERE WAS NO WAY THAT THE ROYAL PARKS COULD BE USED.  YET AGAIN, IT SEEMS THERE IS A DOUBLE STANDARD... Police have told us that they intend to handle the march no differently from the passive way that they have become accustomed to over the course of more than six months. During that time, WE HAVE BECOME ALL TOO USED TO SEEING ANTISEMITIC CHANTS AND PLACARDS at these marches, glorification of terrorism ... Yesterday we met with the Home Secretary and the Minister for Policing to propose concrete measures which can force the police to change their approach. This situation cannot endure much longer and firm action is needed urgently, which we made clear at the meeting.Our Director of Investigations and Enforcement,..., also met with the Metropolitan Police Service yesterday, which told him of its desire to protect Jews walking in the area, but we have a responsibility to be sure that they can. Due to the thousands of people now intending to join and then walk where they please – something that we used to take for granted in London as Jewish people without having to discuss with police ahead of time – we still do not have confidence that people would be safe.ADDITIONALLY WE HAVE RECEIVED NUMEROUS THREATS AND OUR MONITORING HAS IDENTIFIED HOSTILE(S) WHO SEEM TO HAVE INTENDED TO COME TO ANY MEETING LOCATIONS THAT WE ANNOUNCED. THE RISK TO THE SAFETY OF THOSE WHO WISHED TO WALK OPENLY AS JEWS IN LONDON TOMORROW AS PART OF THIS INITIATIVE HAS THEREFORE BECOME TOO GREAT.We are no less angry about these marches than our Jewish community and its allies. WE WANT TO WALK. We want to force the Met to police these marches, not merely manage them. BUT WE CANNOT ENCOURAGE THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE TO WALK WHEN THERE ARE SUCH RISKS TO THEIR SAFETY, AND THERE ARE. We have reluctantly decided not to go ahead tomorrow... Tomorrow, we will watch to see whether anything is different about the way that the Met handles the march, and in the coming week we will progress our discussions with the Government. WE CANNOT ALLOW THE CURRENT SITUATION TO BECOME THE NEW NORMAL.NEEDLESS TO SAY I FOR ONE AM FURIOUS THAT AS A JEWISH WOMAN IT IS DEEMED TOO UNSAFE FOR ME TO WALK AMONG MY FELLOW JEWS TO PROTEST AGAINST ANTISEMITISM IN THIS COUNTRY. My father, who marched with antifascists at Cable Street, is turning in his grave.

Lucille Grant ● 9h1 Comments ● 9h

Odd phenomena - antipathy to Jews; support for Arabs

Am I am misreading or misunderstanding the reaction to the Israel-Palestine conflict; worldwide, in the UK and even amongst some of the white middle class residents of Putney that read this Forum ?Because strange to my way of thinking, any action perpetrated by the Palestinians and other Arabs seems always to be excusable and is explained away by their 'suffering' and experience in the context of an historical and current Middle Eastern conflict.Some people even delve into history to justify the behaviour of Iran, one of the most backward, aggressive and dangerous states on the planet. This being the case even though so many innocent British adults and children have been killed by bomb and knife attacks by Islamist Arabs in the name of their religion, and Iranian infiltrators are thought to be attacking their country's political exiles on our streets.However anything carried out or said by the Jews and the state of Israel seems immediately damned and vilified.And even the word genocide, correctly used to describe the holocaust and the industrialised extermination of six million Jews is misappropriated to describe the unfortunate deaths of Gazan civilians caught up in the current conflict. This is not to excuse every action carried out by Israel and I will not resuscitate the accusations and justifications concerning them made on another thread.However I am unaware of any threat thought posed to British citizens by Israel and Jews and we and the rest of the world have benefited greatly by their enterprise and creativity.Not a claim easily made for Arab states and its citizens, though we do rely on their oil supplies.The current circumstances, issues and actions by the respective political opponents seem to be described bizarrely in ways Lewis Carroll and George Orwell would have recognised.How did the Palestinians and the Islamic world in general achieve such good PR ?  

John Hawkes ● 7d50 Comments ● 1d

Douglas Bader Reception

Went with my other half he had physio today, I waited in reception, before he went in, an elderly lady stood up and turned to me and said I've been waiting 4 hours for a Ambulance to take me home.  I said can I get you a drink of water, so as I walked past the reception I said that lady has been waiting 4 hrs to get home. So I walked across to get her the water, but didn't have a chance as this aggressive receptionist started hurling abuse at me, what's it got to do with you screaming and I mean screaming, waving her arms about.  I still hadn't got the water. So luckily i turned round and 3 men todo with the hospital were standing there, So I said the lady had been waiting ages, I've only come to get her some water.  In the end my other half told her perhaps your in the wrong job. Anyway this went on and on.  My other half was then called in for his appointment. I sat quietly, then the receptionist was having a tea break and made a point of walking past this elderly lady and started talking to her aggressive and pointing her finger at her saying don't start on the Ambulance when he comes, or telling them what to . So after she went out the door I went and sat with the elderly lady to keep her company and to stop the receptionist having another go at her.  The poor lady was sitting really quiet, she was still there when it was time for us to go, making that 5hrs.  The receptionist needs a right talking to.  She wasn't busy or loads of people waiting there was only about 3 people in the waiting room.  She really shouldn't be in the job. This was 2 this afternoon. Queen Mary's Roehampton.

Barbara Stevens ● 7d14 Comments ● 2d