Treatment Delays May Have Contributed to Putney Station Death
Woman suffering from severe postnatal depression took her own life
Westminster Coroners’ Court. Picture: Tony Hisgett
August 9, 2024
A woman with severe postnatal depression took her own life at Putney Station after waiting nearly two months to be put on a waiting list to see an NHS psychiatrist. Judith Obholzer had been advised to admit herself to a private hospital the day before she died in July last year, but she was against this due to money worries.
In a prevention of future deaths report, Ellie Oakley, assistant coroner for Inner West London, said delays in Ms Obholzer’s care may have contributed to her death. An inquest found she died as a result of suicide on July 12, 2023, following a ‘significant period of worsening depressive illness’.
The report found there were delays by South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust in assessing Ms Obholzer and adding her to the waiting list for a full assessment by a consultant psychiatrist. It said a private psychiatrist who she visited the day before she died could not directly access crisis support for her.
A trust spokesperson said providing timely care to patients is its highest priority and it is ‘deeply sorry’ for falling short of that in Ms Obholzer’s case. A Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) spokesperson pledged to fix the ‘broken’ mental health system so that patients get the care they deserve.
Ms Obholzer had been suffering from depression and anxiety since at least March 2023. Her GP had prescribed her antidepressants and she started seeing a private practitioner weekly for cognitive behavioural treatment on 12 March.
Her GP referred her to the Wandsworth single point of access (SPA) team, which manages patient referrals to mental health services, on 15 May and she was assessed by a triage nurse on 18 May. However, she was not put on the waiting list for an assessment by a consultant psychiatrist until 10 July. During this time, she was experiencing thoughts of suicide and planning.
The report found there was a delay within the SPA team, which led to a delay in putting Ms Obholzer on the waiting list. It said there was no sharing of medical notes between NHS providers and private practitioners which, along with other factors, led to delays in the team putting together a treatment plan. It added it was unclear whether she would have been assessed by the time of her death without the delays due to the waiting times patients were already facing.
Ms Obholzer attended a consultation with a private consultant psychiatrist on 11 July due to the decline in her condition and the wait for NHS care. The psychiatrist diagnosed her with severe postnatal depression and found she was at significant risk of suicide.
The psychiatrist recommended Ms Obholzer admit herself to a private hospital, according to the report, but she was against this due to financial concerns. He planned to write to her GP to request an urgent assessment by a local crisis team, but he did not send the letter that day.
The psychiatrist later gave evidence that he was not able to refer patients directly to NHS crisis teams as a direct alternative to voluntary treatment at a private hospital. The report said that while the trust provided evidence that direct referrals could be made, the exact procedure for this was unclear. It added the psychiatrist was also unable to send the urgent letter to her GP in part because their details had not been provided.
The coroner sent the report to the trust, NHS England and DHSC after raising concerns that ‘future deaths will occur unless action is taken’.
The report said, “In the course of the evidence it was confirmed that there is significant pressure on NHS mental health services. It seems likely that there will be an increase in patients obtaining private support while waiting for NHS support (and often only being able to afford such support for a limited time and to a limited extent and doing so only while waiting for NHS support), as happened in this case.
“Consideration should be given to ensuring that there is sufficient clarity in processes such as referrals and crisis support where private practitioners are providing treatment as well as the NHS, ensuring sharing of information and notes where relevant and necessary and ensuring that the NHS provision is not assessed as unnecessary simply because someone has obtained private support as an interim measure.”
A South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust spokesperson said, “We extend our heartfelt condolences to Ms Obholzer’s loved ones. Providing timely care to our patients is our highest priority, and we are deeply sorry that we fell short of that on this occasion. Since then, we have completed a full investigation and taken several actions to reduce delays for patients needing an urgent assessment.
“Anyone can call or make a referral about anyone they’re concerned for to our crisis services via our mental health crisis telephone line (0800 028 8000), including any clinician or organisation outside of our Trust. We are taking further steps to raise awareness of the referral process.”
A DHSC spokesperson added, “Our deepest sympathies are with Mrs Obholzer’s family and friends in this tragic case. It is important that we learn the lessons from every prevention of future deaths report and the department will consider the report carefully before responding in due course.
“People with mental health issues are not getting the support or care they deserve, which is why we will fix the broken system to ensure we give mental health the same attention and focus as physical health.”
When life is difficult, Samaritans are here – day or night, 365 days a year. You can call them for free on 116 123, email them at jo@samaritans.org, or visit samaritans.org to find your nearest branch.
Charlotte Lilywhite - Local Democracy Reporter