Forum Topic

Ms Bond'You don't mention - you probably don't even consider - the increase in Islamophobia in this country'.Have you noticed this increase ?Can you point to some examples of it ?Are Muslims in Tooting running scared ?Did not Muslims commandeer Trafalgar Square for a mass 'pray in' ?Did not crowds chant 'death to the IDF' at al-Quds rally in London ?Are not Tower Hamlets and parts of Birmingham and Bradford not enclaves of Bangladeshi and Pakistani Islamic immigrants that now control the areas ?Powerful enough to be emboldened to protest at the effrontery of a Christian street preacher publicly proclaiming his beliefs and challenge his right to do so in 'their area' ?Has any policing body or civilian group tried to do the same when the activists are Muslims ? 'you will find Jews marching against the behaviour of the Israeli Government'.I am sure there are some 'Jews marching against the behaviour of the Israeli Government.'They can do that in a democratic state with open free speech.Not so in Islamic Iran I understand as you can see described below from a reputable Arab news media.And yes, some Jewish citizens have taken it upon themselves to encroach on territory in the West Bank of what is claimed to be Palestine.But certainly not supported or encouraged by the Israeli government even if some Knesset members do so.'Israel's behaviour towards other inhabitants in the area as you will see from the above article'.Can you describe some of this behaviour that you find so reprehensible ?Is at worse than that carried out by Islamic Arab terrorists  against Jewish civilians in their attack on Israel in October 2023 ?Simple 'yes/no' will suffice.A key question surely is 'were there many Iranians marching against the behaviour of the Iranian Government in Tehran' ?The answer is a brave few but for 2986 of them it did not end well.Aljazeera - 19 Jan 2026'Tehran, Iran – Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has acknowledged that “several thousands” of Iranians have been killed since protests started in late December among shopkeepers in downtown Tehran, before gradually spreading to big and small cities'.Keep up defending the indefensible.Why should a resident of West Putney like yourself do so unless harbouring  an irrational hatred to Israel and the Jews ?

John Hawkes ● 26d

No comment about the campus aspect because I didn’t go to uni and started work at 16.I don’t recall any significant anti-Jewish sentiments during the 60’s, 70’s and 80’s.  My late partner of over 40 years was half-Jewish (from his Mother’s side) and I never heard any antisemitic comments when out with him.  Maybe that was because he didn’t ‘look’ Jewish ie he didn’t wear a kippah.  His business partner was Jewish and their jewellery business was in Hatton Garden where many of their colleagues were Jews, but as far as I know none of them were subjected to any serious antisemitism.  Perhaps they were just lucky, I don’t know.🤷🏻‍♀️In my opinion antisemitism has overtly surfaced over the past 25 - 30 years and it is now rife; sadly even this forum displays a microcosm of it.The Muslim population in the UK has experienced significant growth over the last 30 years; roughly doubling in the last 15 years to over 3.9 million(6.5%) in 2021. Muslim population - huge increase Antisemitism - huge increaseCoincidence? AI overview:Between 2011 and 2021 alone, the number of Muslims in England and Wales increased by 1.16 million, representing 33% of the total population increase during that decade.Key Growth Data (2011–2021 Census Analysis)* Rapid Growth: The Muslim population increased by 44% in a decade, growing from 2.71 million in 2011 to 3.87 million in 2021.* Overall Proportion: Muslims now make up 6.5% of the total population in England and Wales, up from 4.8% in 2011.* Population Structure: Over 50% of the Muslim population was born in the UK, signaling a shift from a primarily immigrant population to a more settled, younger demographic.* Regional Concentration: Major cities have high concentrations, with significant Muslim populations in Birmingham, Bradford, and London boroughs like Tower Hamlets and Newham.

Sue Hammond ● 27d

Mr Ixer'There's still racism in football, but the authorities do seem to take steps to resolve that?  I agree racism is unacceptable but surely one needs to understand what creates such prejudices?'When was the last time you went to a professional football match ?Who do you support ?I am a season ticket holder at Fulham FC and have NEVER heard or seen examples of racism.For many reasons.Firstly the grounds are tightly policed and stewarded.Racist chants and actions are quickly pointed out to officials by the mass of fans and the miscreants ejected from the ground.  Secondly and more apposite practically every UK team is made up of at least 50% of players that are not only non-British but are also non-white!And many display their religious commitments quite openly.Even we football supporters are not so thick as to insult and abuse our own.PS Arsenal or City for the Carabao Cup on Sunday ?Regarding prejudice more widely I have no doubt that the vast majority of we British are quite able to take anyone as they find them on a day to day basis regardless of skin colour or ethnicity.Unless on this Forum and their name is Trump !However feelings by the white majority towards differing ethnic and religious groups are strongly influenced by the behaviour of such even if this is over or misreported.Examples being knife based crime by Afro-Caribbean gangs and antisemitic and anti-British prejudice and cultural isolationism by Islamic groups.  Sadly apolitical and areligious individuals suffer from this unfortunate but often understandable group prejudice.

John Hawkes ● 27d

Mr Ainsworth'"How is it even tolerable that 20% or anyone in this day and age judges someone else only because of their religion?"'I am sure that the Palestians would agree.Best to judge people by what they do, don't you think?'Would Palestinians really want to be judged on their actions ?These are the people that invaded Israel from Gaza in 2023 and murdered, raped and kidnapped thousands of the elderly, women and children and only recently returned the corpses and remains of many so defiled.Doubtless to you an inconsequential set of actions in the fight for Palestinian freedom and a recognised state.At least I don't recall you condemning it with the venom and regularity with which you attack the actions of Israel.Why is that ?And who have murdered many UK citizens on the streets of Britain in the last few decades - Jews and non-Jews alike.Actions soon gaslit by denials and claims of Israeli atrocities by the likes of you.(BTW what do you consider should be the boundaries of Palestine and who is its elected government?)'"As explosions were heard across Tehran and air defense systems were activated, Effie Defrin, a spokesperson for the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), said the Israeli military still has thousands of targets left to strike across Iran, with new targets being identified every day.".Knowing that, would one not think a sensible Iranian regime would make it quite clear it harbours no malice towards Israel and allow full international inspection to convince the world it has no plans to develop nuclear weapons ?Unless of course it does and has 😉

John Hawkes ● 27d

Steven'A report published by the Union of Jewish Students has found that- 20% of university students won’t flatshare with Jews- 26% believe that calling for Zionists to be removed from campus is not anti-Semitic- 24% believe that saying Zionists control the media is not anti- Semitic- 18% believe that saying ‘globalise the intifada’ is not anti-Semitic- 13% believe that a symbol of a Star of David intertwined with a swastika is not anti-Semitic- 11% believe that denying or downplaying the Holocaust is not anti-Semitic.'Various reasons for this -1) With the vast expansion of the 'university sector' (?) encouraged by Blair anyone seems to be eligible to 'go to university'.And the university they find is more concerned with DEI rather than 'thinking' and learning.Hence herd-like positions regarding Jews are taken up based upon ethnicity and the current political zeitgeist ie antisemitism. Sometimes supported by 'the faculty'.2) The percent of Jews in the UK population is 0.5% and Muslims 6.5%.Add to this a proportion of other/non-religion affiliated students that are possibly antisemitic one can easily see how the attitudes and numbers of people holding such views is arrived at.And let's not forget, many of these students possibly have parents whose antisemitic opinions are well represented by middle class leftist contributors to this Forum and have passed these opinions on to their offspring.It is strange that thinking back to my time at university in the '60s this issue never raised its ugly head.

John Hawkes ● 27d

I too am staggered by the response, Robert. Racism is often ascribed to ignorance. Yet the poll shows that gross anti-Semitism is widespread among university students, supposedly among the brightest of the new generation. While the poll was commissioned by the Union of Jewish students, it was conducted by JL Partners, an established polling organisation who surveyed a representative sample of 1000 students. I don’t know whether the results were further broken down by age, gender, ethnicity and so on, but whether they were or not, this does not affect the overall conclusion. If the questionnaire contained just one question, ‘Would you flatshare with a Jew?’, there might be an innocent explanation. But the answers to the other questions leave no doubt about the extent of anti-Semitism. One of the most chilling is the support for a ‘global intifada’ among almost one in five students. Global intifada if it means anything at all means attacking Jews and Jewish institutions throughout the world. Almost as chilling is the view held by over a quarter of respondents that Zionists should be removed from the campus. Since the vast majority of Jewish people support the existence of the State of Israel, this means that over one in four university students believe in the mass expulsion of Jews from their universities. And by the way,  I hardly think the pollsters needed to check whether university students understand the meaning of anti-Semitism. In any case a poll on anti-Semitism  is not a sociology exam. It is designed to illuminate attitudes, not test the philosophical knowledge of the respondents.

Steven Rose ● 28d

So, on average, over 80% (about 2 and a half million) DISAGREE with those 6 statements.Perhaps the positive figures of 80%, 74%, 76%, 82%, 87%, 89% would be more helpful.-----------------------Meanwhile:-Preferential Treatment: According to a Pew Research Center study, 79% of Israeli Jews believe that Jews in Israel deserve "preferential treatment" over non-Jewish citizens.The Concept of "Chosenness": A 2009 survey found that 70% of Israeli Jews believe Jews are the "chosen people". While many interpret this as a religious responsibility rather than a claim of superiority, some critics and secular Israelis view it as a form of ethnic chauvinism.Political Framing: In recent political discourse, critics and some former security officials have described the current government's platform as one of "Jewish supremacy," particularly regarding land rights in the West Bank. Proponents of these policies, however, often frame them as a matter of "Jewish self-determination" or historical right.Comparison with Palestinians: In specific contexts, such as a Berman Jewish DataBank report, certain segments of the population explicitly link their Zionist identity to a belief that Jews are superior to Palestinians, though this is not a majority view among those who identify as "Zionist".---------------------According to a 2025 study:56% of Israeli Jews supported the "transfer (forced expulsion) of Arab citizens of Israel to other countries".The same survey found that 82% of Israeli Jews supported the forced expulsion of Palestinians from the Gaza Strip.The poll also found that 47% of respondents agreed that the IDF should act in a manner similar to the biblical conquest of Jericho (interpreted as killing all inhabitants) when conquering an enemy city.Published by the Israeli newspaper Haaretz on June 3, 2025.It's good that 53% didn't want to kill all the inhabitants, isn't it? (Though there is room for some improvement there)

David Ainsworth ● 29d