Forum Topic

Ms Bond'Matthew Goodwin seems to be one of those people who peddles the ridiculous idea that many British people aren't British because either they or their parents happened to not have been born in the UK.  That isn't clever - it's stupid.  That insinuates that there are a greater number of newer immigrants to the country than there are but I've seen this allegation before'.Is it not be true that if you were not born in the UK, you must have a right to citizenship in your actual country of birth, and that there must be special processes you should have to go through in order to be able to claim to be a British citizen ?Or can anyone get on a ferry or get in a dinghy and on arrival claim to be British ?Is that your ideal ?Here is Government data that backs up what you call 'allegations'."What are the UK’s latest migrations statistics?"https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn06077/The latest estimates on migration from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) suggest that in 2024:948,000 people migrated into the UK and 513,000 people emigrated from it, leaving a net migration figure of 431,000. This represents the balance of long-term migrants moving in and out of the country.The latest ONS population estimates for the whole of the UK suggest that, in the year ending June 2021, there were:6.0 million people were living in the UK who had the nationality of a different country (9% of the total population). This does not include dual nationals where one nationality is British.3.4 million EU nationals (excluding UK) were living in the UKA more recent, ad hoc estimate by the ON indicated that, as of June 2023, there were around 11.4 million non-UK-born residents of England and Wales, including 3.4 million EU-born and 8.0 million non-EU born. This was equivalent to around 18% of the England and Wales population'.

John Hawkes ● 25d

Ms BondLet me remind you that "Matthew Goodwin, an academic, bestselling author, pollster, and speaker known for his research on: politics, populism, elections, voting, public opinion, Brexit, Europe, academic freedom and more. He is Professor of Politics at Rutherford College, University of Kent, recently served as Senior Visiting Fellow at the Royal Institute of International Affairs, at Chatham House, Senior Fellow with the UK In a Changing Europe, Senior Fellow at the Legatum Institute, and Senior Advisor to the UK Education Committee. In 2022, Matt was appointed Social Mobility Commissioner".You claim ""Matthew James Goodwin (born December 1981) is a British right-wing political commentator, political scientist, and former academic recognised for his research on populism and right-wing movements. He is currently a presenter at GB News."Your source ?What is your definition of 'right wing' ?Why is the fact that alongside being a respected academic (or why would these academic and Government institutions employ him) what has the fact that presents at GB News to do with the price of fish ? For your information he is also a member of the Government body the Social Mobility Commission.'Minister for Women and Equalities, Liz Truss, appoints 7 new commissioners to Social Mobility Commission boardThe appointments will support Katharine Birbalsingh in her role as Chair of the SMCThe new board members will advance the independent work of the SMC following this year’s State of the Nation reportDr Raghib Ali, Resham Kotecha, Matthew Goodwin, Ryan Henson, Rob Henderson*, Parminder Kohli and Rob Wilson have been appointed to the Board for a period of 4 years. They will make up a new panel of advisers from diverse ethnic backgrounds, with expertise stretching from academia to education and business'.Would you like to indicate which of these members are right wing and which are left wing ?And let's hope none of them write for the Guardian ?

John Hawkes ● 25d

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14844067/Israeli-minister-Jewish-people-quit-Britain.html'An Israeli minister has warned British Jews to leave the UK unless there is a change of government and blamed Labour for fuelling anti-Semitism.Amichai Chikli, Israel's minister of diaspora affairs, accused the Labour Government of being one of the most hostile towards Israel 'we have ever known'.Mr Chikli is a member of the Right-wing Likud party and has been outspoken in his views on anti-Semitism in Britain.In his latest remarks, he told the Mail: 'Without a dramatic change of course by Britain's political leadership, I see no future for Jewish life in England.'My recommendation to Jews in the UK is to consider leaving and make aliyah to the Land of Israel. 'Imposing sanctions on Israeli elected officials whose views the Labour Party dislikes crosses every red line between friendly nations.'Mr Chikli said he had 'no doubt Labour's hostile policy toward Israel, beyond its suicidal political correctness, is also driven by simple electoral arithmetic'. (TRUE - all those Parliamentary seats where Muslim votes are crucial).He added: 'I will never forget how, during the second hostage-release deal, Starmer issued a condemnation after Eli Sharabi was freed – starved and looking like a concentration camp survivor – yet he did not dare mention Hamas by name. 'He knows full well that England's Hamas sympathisers are a significant part of his base. (OUCH !)'On the domestic front, in the very same breath that they announce a ban on Palestine Action as a terrorist organization, they permit dozens of marches where chants of 'jihad' and 'from the river to the sea' are heard. 'And one must not forget the threats to arrest lone Jews on the grounds that they are 'provoking' simply by their presence or by holding critical signs near Hamas-supporter protests.'It is not the first time Labour has come under fire by the Israeli government. In an interview with the Mail last September, Israel's prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu accused the Prime Minister of 'sending a horrible message' to Hamas after the UK Government suspended a raft of arms licences to Israel.

John Hawkes ● 28d

Ms Grant'video of a police officer harassing a Jewish man at yesterday's Palestine Action demo.'I agree what you describe looks bad, but I don't think we should blame the two coppers.They are placed in a difficult situation created by the actions of an  antisemitic Islam supporting mob and I am sure they were doing their best to keep the peace.I would hazard a guess at what they really think about the cause of 'Palestinian freedom' and the people that take to our streets to proclaim and support it and what they would really like to do to them.But their hands are tied.People who in the main are not British citizens but for some reason have the right to abide here and create all the mayhem they wish.People too cowardly to take their fight, if that is what they want, to their Palestinian homeland.But no Prets there for refreshment after the march of course.We are a soft touch when it comes to allowing political protest regarding issues in which we have no interest onto our streets and disrupting our way of life.Luckily I understand the Home Secretary is going to add Palestinian Action to the ever growing list of proscribed Islamist groups, lead by Hamas.But I do offer 'A Modest Proposal'.I read that Venice, for reasons of overcrowding and the despoiling of its fabric and atmosphere, charges tourists for visiting it.Perhaps we should do the same in London regarding protests by foreigners for foreign causes."Want to enter Whitehall ? Show me your passport. Palestinian eh, Well that costs twenty quid. Move along please".

John Hawkes ● 29d

For those of you who have access to the Daily Telegraph (highly unlikely you'll see this reported in the Guardian or FT) there is a video of a police officer harassing a Jewish man at yesterday's Palestine Action demo. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/06/24/police-jewish-man-on-bus-palestine-action-protest/Here is the transcript of the article. Met officers warn two counter-protesters that their actions could be breach of peace after they were forced to hide on bus The Metropolitan Police has been accused of “two-tier” policing after a Jewish man said officers threatened to charge him for waving an Israeli flag at a Palestine Action demonstration.The protest group clashed with police in Trafalgar Square on Monday, with 13 arrested after violence flared within the crowd of 500 activists.But the Met was accused of “two-tier” justice over the actions of its officers after two Jewish counter-protesters had to hide inside a double-decker bus as the “mob” outside chanted “Zionist scum”.Footage shared with The Telegraph showed police warning them that “waving an Israeli flag” could be a breach of the peace.Isaac Grand, 22, and another Jewish man, 28, who declined to be named, accused the Met of “two-tier policing” over the threat.Mr Grand said: “It was a clear case of two-tier policing. A hostile mob surrounded the vehicle, shouting abuse and threatening me – but instead of protecting me or arresting those responsible, the police threatened me with a public order offence.”Mr Grand and his friend started their two-person counter-demonstration against the group, which is soon to be proscribed as a terrorist group, by waving the Israeli flag.Using a megaphone, Mr Grand’s companion told the crowd: “Ban the IRGC [Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps]. Rape is not resistance. Terrorist supporters off our streets. Am Yisrael Chai [the people of Israel live], now and forever.”But when the hostile crowd surrounded the pair and chanted “Zionist scum!”, they had to board a nearby double-decker that had been blocked by the protest.As they were taken to the bus, the two men shouted and swore back at the pro-Palestine protesters who were chanting slurs at them.Footage on board filmed by Mr Grand, a trainee barrister, shows him being told by a Met officer: “You are creating a breach of the peace.”Mr Grand replied: “What did I do, officer?” to which he replied: “You’re waving an Israeli flag.”Asked by Mr Grand if it was a criminal offence, the officer said: “No it’s not. But it is now... look at them protesting for Palestine.”Mr Grand argued that he had merely exercised his rights to free speech and protest.The officer then said: “Yeah, yeah, but there’s a time and a place, isn’t there?”He went on to say: “You’re perfectly within your right to protest, but I’m not going to let two rival protest groups clash, yeah? That’s why you’re on here [the bus].”Later, Mr Grand told The Telegraph that the fracas was provoked when “a young man from the crowd grabbed the flag”, with his companion adding that the crowd had attempted “to topple us to the ground”.His companion said: “I’m sure it would have devolved into a much worse situation had the police not got there so quickly.”Mr Grand continued: “At that point the bus was surrounded by this big Palestinian mob. It was terrifying.“We had already been harassed, then they grabbed our flag, now we were trapped on this bus. It didn’t seem like the police had any control over the situation. It seems to be almost anarchy at these protests.“It’s simply terrifying to exercise your rights to freedom of protest. You can’t have an opinion in this country. The Met Police won’t let you.”He said that he intends to make a complaint about the officers’ conduct.It is understood that officers were seeking to protect the Jewish men from danger and recognised the risks of releasing them into the crowd alone.The men left the protest unharmed on foot with a policeman escorting them, whom they thanked when they parted ways.A Met Police spokesman said: “This was a challenging protest which saw 13 arrests and a number of officers assaulted.“Protesters surrounded police officers on multiple occasions and when two counter protesters started waving an Israeli flag and shouting on a megaphone, they surrounded them too.“Officers intervened to protect the two men. They were held on an out of service bus for their own safety and not because they had committed a crime. When it was safe to do so, officers escorted them out of the area.“As the officer explained at the time, the men had every right to protest, but it was unwise for two people to walk into a crowd of 500 people with opposing views and not expect a confrontation to follow. Had the situation been reversed with 500 pro-Israel supporters and two pro-Palestinian, the officers would have done the same thing.”The video is worth the watch. Two tier policing in action?You will now understand why I no longer visit central London at all. My own hometown where I was born 77 years ago! Frankly, I would like to be there but my partner and children are worried for my safety.

Lucille Grant ● 29d

Mr Pike'Do you still march with these thugs on a Saturday Mr Carter?'"Tut, tut".These are not thugs but freedom fighters against Zionist oppression, apartheid and genocide directed against peaceful, oppressed downtrodden Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank.I expect he will also be on the streets today amongst the members of Palestine Action, the group behind the attack on RAF Brize Norton.Doubtless that will possibly give him the chance of talking to the group's spokesperson Saeed Taji Farouky, whose name would indicate that he obviously  represents the views of most Britons, about the following -https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c307n9p43z9o"Suicide bombing at Damascus church kills 22, Syrian authorities say" 'At least 22 people have been killed and 63 others wounded in a suicide bomb attack at a church in Damascus, Syria's health ministry has said.A man opened fire with a weapon at the Greek Orthodox Church of the Prophet Elias in the Dweila neighbourhood during a service on Sunday evening before detonating an explosive vest, according to the interior ministry.It said the attacker was affiliated with the jihadist group Islamic State (IS). There was no immediate claim from the group itself.Photos and video from inside the church showed a heavily damaged altar, pews covered in broken glass and blood spattered across the walls'.I don't think the IDF were involved in this Islamist religious massacre but doubtless one or two people on this Forum will come back to me with links to obscure Arabic news media to prove me wrong, and it was all just a diversionary action by Netanyahu.

John Hawkes ● 30d

Ms Grant 'Sadly this is by no means a unique experience.I continue to wear my (small) Star of David alongside my yellow hostage pin. My partner has noticed the hostile looks I get when I'm on the tube, bus or train. The anti semitism being experienced in the UK and in particular in London is the highest I've ever known in my lifetime. We are a very small minority ethnic community and yet this is what we face on a daily basis. Israel's actions may have inadvertently provided a latent hatred of Jews to surface. We are not responsible for the Israeli government just as most of the Muslim population here are not responsible for the actions of Arab countries'.You are too forgiving.England, even leafy Southfields, is becoming more and more Islamised with its increasing numbers of Middle Eastern immigrants and an ignorant, leftist student class. Apropos of what you write, the pro-Palestine anti-Jewish zeitgeist has developed to an extent that on the timetable at the bus stop near the AELTC someone is attaching 'sticky labels' that say "PALESTINE BELONGS TO THE PALESTINIANS NOT TO THE ZIONISTS".Waiting for the 493 I pass my time scraping them off.I am not an expert by any means on the rise of Naziism in Germany (though I have read "The Coming of the Third Reich"  by British historian Richard J. Evans - recommended !).It describes the origins of the Nazi Party and the circumstances that led to its gaining control of the Weimar Republic, covering the period from the unification of Germany in 1871 through the First World War and the interwar period to 1933, when Adolf Hitler and the Nazis seized power in Germany.One of many things that stuck in my mind was the gathering antipathy towards the Jews by a despondent and demoralised German people after WWI who needed someone to blame.That might partly explain Palestinian atrocities but not the support of such by their white, bourgeoise English fellow travellers.One propagandising technique was the posting of defamatory pamphlets on walls.A small but effective one.Jews were the victims of 'the right' then.Now it seems to be 'the left' that are doing the persecution.But don't lose heart.You have the support of people that can see the difference between right and wrong.

John Hawkes ● 31d

Ms Grant.'As a Jewish family, with young children, we faced racial abuse going into central London today. We didn't realise that our route into a central London venue popular with children would take us into the path of people going into the marches.'Commiserations to your friend.It is not unreasonable to see these marches as anti-Jewish in nature as much as pro-Palestinian.It is also well known that antisemitism is growing world wide and in the UK for I believe the following reasons.a) I would expect a majority of illegal immigrants ('boat people') have Middle East and Islamic origins and antisemitic tendencies and that this incompetent Labour Government has no idea how to keep them out or send them back where they came from.Though a review of or withdrawal from the restrictions of the ECHR might help if Reform stiffens their backbone.b) Media and academic opinion as well as leftist politics is rabidly anti-Israel (meaning anti-Jewish) for its so called genocide (sic) of the Palestinians (probably including Hamas).This is just cover for its antisemitism and to hide the fact that Israel is a thriving democratic entity and Palestine is a ...well what ?c) The youth of today especially students are totally ignorant of world affairs and history, particularly regarding the Middle East.They are simply driven, commendably in their eyes, by 'empathy for the poor and downtrodden' not reality.One Facebook or Guardian picture of an emaciated Palestinian child is all it takes, for that is all they have time for before scrolling on to a picture of Dua Lipa, to convince them of how wicked the Jews are. Or perhaps it is caused by posts of the anti-Israel/anti-Jewish faction on this Forum.

John Hawkes ● 31d