Forum Topic

This is apparently the full text of the letter:Former President of Poland Lech Walesa wrote the following letter to Trump.Your Excellency, Mr. President,We watched the report of your conversation with the President of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky, with fear and distaste. We find it insulting that you expect Ukraine to show respect and gratitude for the material assistance provided by the United States in its fight against russia. Gratitude is owed to the heroic Ukrainian soldiers who shed their blood in defense of the values of the free world. They have been dying on the front lines for more than 11 years in the name of these values and the independence of their homeland, which was attacked by Putin’s russia.We do not understand how the leader of a country that symbolizes the free world cannot recognize this.Our alarm was also heightened by the atmosphere in the Oval Office during this conversation, which reminded us of the interrogations we endured at the hands of the Security Services and the debates in Communist courts. Prosecutors and judges, acting on behalf of the all-powerful communist political police, would explain to us that they held all the power while we held none. They demanded that we cease our activities, arguing that thousands of innocent people suffered because of us. They stripped us of our freedoms and civil rights because we refused to cooperate with the government or express gratitude for our oppression. We are shocked that President Volodymyr Zelensky was treated in the same manner.The history of the 20th century shows that whenever the United States sought to distance itself from democratic values and its European allies, it ultimately became a threat to itself. President Woodrow Wilson understood this when he decided in 1917 that the United States must join World War I. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt understood this when, after the attack on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, he resolved that the war to defend America must be fought not only in the Pacific but also in Europe, in alliance with the nations under attack by the Third Reich.We remember that without President Ronald Reagan and America’s financial commitment, the collapse of the Soviet empire would not have been possible. President Reagan recognized that millions of enslaved people suffered in Soviet russia and the countries it had subjugated, including thousands of political prisoners who paid for their defense of democratic values with their freedom. His greatness lay, among other things, in his unwavering decision to call the USSR an “Empire of Evil” and to fight it decisively. We won, and today, the statue of President Ronald Reagan stands in Warsaw, facing the U.S. Embassy.Mr. President, material aid—military and financial—can never be equated with the blood shed in the name of Ukraine’s independence and the freedom of Europe and the entire free world. Human life is priceless; its value cannot be measured in money. Gratitude is due to those who sacrifice their blood and their freedom. This is self-evident to us, the people of Solidarity, former political prisoners of the communist regime under Soviet russia.We call on the United States to uphold the guarantees made alongside Great Britain in the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, which established a direct obligation to defend Ukraine’s territorial integrity in exchange for its relinquishment of nuclear weapons. These guarantees are unconditional—there is no mention of treating such assistance as an economic transaction.Signed,Lech Wałęsa, former political prisoner, President of Poland

Michael Ixer ● 29d

When some would damn Trump as a fascist and a dictator I used to poo poo the notion.But in his approach to politics I now concede he is little different from Putin though of course there are some constraints made upon him by Congress, the Senate, the Supreme Court and ultimately the US voters that Putin never need be bothered about. My consoling thought is that in reality he does not have the power to really harm us and Western Europe which thankfully, apart from Hungary, sees him for what he is - an aging, botoxed, spray tanned ignoramus who won't be around long politically or otherwise.But what he has done is to point out to us that we cannot and probably never should have relied on the US to defend us and so the Chancellor should certainly put defence spending much higher up on her list.Reducing welfare payments and forcing more into work might fund some of it.The US is not an ally but just a business partner and should be treated as such.The EU commission reports that - 'EU-US goods and services trade is balanced: the difference between EU exports to the US and US exports to the EU stood at €48 billion in 2023; the equivalent of just 3% of the total trade between the EU and the US'. We should just quietly go about trying to maintain this and if he slaps tariffs on us we should reciprocate.Pity Starmer inadvertently mistimed his US visit so badly, but he has time to redress this when he meets Zelensky in London. What of course will screw the US in the end is -a) Russia will be a very unreliable ally.b) China will slowly screw them when it comes to world trade as it will have more and more economic influence in Africa, the Far East and Asia.Oh, this time I think it correct and proper for Mayor Khan to get out the Trump blimp !

John Hawkes ● 32d

I watched the press conference three times and I have read the transcript. I can see no evidence that Zelensky attacked the United States.  On the contrary Zelensky was personally attacked by Trump and Vance. He was told  he ‘hated’ Putin, he was ‘disrespectful’, he was ungrateful. He was told Ukraine had problems getting men to fight, that Ukraine would have been defeated in a week had it not been for American military aid.Zelensky’s mistake was in trying to reply, honestly though not always tactfully, to some of these attacks, In reply to Vance’s point that the conflict should be solved by diplomacy, Zelensky said that Ukraine had tried diplomacy but Putin had broken  previous agreements. He listed the American administrations under which this happened, which Vance took as a criticism of the United States though I don’t think Zelensky meant it in that way. He replied to Vance’s jibe that Ukraine had problems by saying that all countries had problems , including America, but America had thousands of miles of ocean to protect it from Russia. He suggested that one day Russia might be a problem for America, a comment to which Trump took exception. Zelensky said that Vance should come to Ukraine to see the situation for himself, which Vance interpreted as an accusation that he didn’t know what he was talking about. Zelensky said he needed American guarantees that Russia wouldn’t use a ceasefire to attack again, whereupon Trump told him he was in no position to dictate terms.My conclusion is that Trump and Vance treated Zelensky abominably and Zelensky was a little tactless in his replies. He probably should have stayed silent throughout the press conference.

Steven Rose ● 32d