Forum Topic

Comment from today's Spectator -'The images (//published by Hamas//) of Eli Sharabi, Or Levy, and Ohad Ben Ami – three hostages released by Hamas after 491 days in captivity – were haunting. Frail, skeletal, barely able to stand, they bore the unmistakable marks of prolonged deprivation. The sight evoked painful historical echoes: men whose suffering was etched into their hollowed faces and emaciated bodies, a vision chillingly reminiscent of Holocaust survivors. This was not incidental malnutrition. It was something far worse: starvation as a weapon, inflicted with intent.The contrast was stark. The Hamas terrorists escorting the hostages looked well-fed, as did the civilians who gathered to jeer at the released men and to scatter confetti. Some were positively fat. Hamas had the means to sustain these captives: it chose not to. Their condition was not an accident of war but a deliberate act of cruelty.The physical condition of the hostages told only part of the story. Their testimonies have begun to reveal the true extent of the suffering they endured. Or Levy and Ohad Ben Ami described BRUTAL INTERROGATIONS in which they were subjected to RELENTLESS TORTURE: hanging upside down by their feet, strangled, gagged to the point of suffocation, and even branded with burning objects.They were kept barefoot throughout their captivity, left alone for long stretches in suffocating, cramped conditions deep within Hamas’ tunnels, unable to stand or move freely. They were deliberately starved, at times receiving nothing at all for days on end; when they were given food, it was often little more than rotten scraps of pitta bread, which they had to share among multiple prisoners.Even water was withheld for long periods. “We were treated like animals,” one of them said. Only in the final days before their release did their captors begin to offer slightly more sustenance –just enough to ensure they could remain upright long enough for the cameras. It was not just cruelty, but calculated and systematic dehumanisation, inflicted over 491 days of captivity'.From JusticeInfo.net -'In December 2019, the International Criminal Court (ICC) added starvation as a war crime to their statute. This is a crime recognized by the Geneva Conventions'Should not ICC prosecutor Karim Asad Ahmad Khan KC who specialises in international criminal law and international human rights law be summoning Hamas leaders to stand trial ?Does he not recognise how barbaric Hamas Palestinians are or is he intent on self-publicity with his demands that Netanyahu stand trial for war crimes ?The hypocrisy is sickening and I hope Forum readers recognise the fact and can distinguish between good and evil in this conflict.

John Hawkes ● 87d

Mr BrigoYou claim - 'He is a displaced high school teacher, rounded up from one of the tent camps, abducted and transported to a torture prison in December 2023 and held until yesterday without ever being charged with a crime'.This, if true, begs the question "why pick on him" ?There might be reasonable suspicion that he is a Palestinian terrorist.Or it might make him an unfortunate victim of collateral damage in the defensive war Israel is fighting against the Palestinians who do not believe the state of Israel should exist and wish to annihilate its Jewish citizens.Note the date he was supposedly abducted - two months after the invasion of Israel by Palestinians and the pogrom that took place in October 2023 resulting in the murder, sexual assaults and abduction of women, children and the elderly, many of whom are still being held.But, was the man tortured ?And did the circumstances of attacks against Israel not inevitably mean that due process of the law was not able to be fully carried out ?And have not he and many others now been released which is more than can be said of the hostages taken by the Palestinians in October 2023, assuming they have not already been murdered ? You are obviously a passionate defender of the Palestinians and the actions they have taken.However some questions for you -1) do you believe Israel has the right to exist as a sovereign state on the territory it now resides ?2) do you support those Palestinians who do NOT believe it has the right and wish to annihilate its citizens ?3) do you believe the attack on Israel by Palestinians in October 2023 was justified ?Y/N answers will suffice.

John Hawkes ● 87d