Forum Topic

Ms GrantYour GP is obviously a fine ironist.From Wikipedia -'GPs are officially classed as independent contractors, although most think of themselves as being part of the NHS. This status dates back to the beginning of the NHS and was intended to keep costs down while allowing GPs to maintain their independence from NHS management. While GP practices are private businesses, this does not necessarily mean that they are in favor of further commercialization of General Practice by large companies'.Of course they are not in favour.They do very nicely thank you as things are.Again Wikipedia -'The average salary for a GP is currently £98,000 a year according to the latest research. However, this figure is merely a guide, as GP salaries can vary enormously. Many less experienced GPs earn just over £60,000 a year, while a handful of the most experienced can earn more than £200,000 by managing several practices and thousands of patients'.You should ask what your GP means by 'privatising the NHS'.Many services are delivered by private companies under contract to the NHS.Dentistry is one in particular and 526,000 elective operations were performed by private medical companies on behalf of the NHS.The whole situation is summed up nicely below -'The issue of privatisation of health services was a topic of debate during the 2015 United Kingdom general election. The government's main stance is summed up in this quote: "(the) use of the private sector in the NHS represents only 6% of the total NHS budget - an increase of just 1% since May 2010".[23] It is unclear what this statement meant. Some NHS services, such as dentistry, optical care and pharmacy, have always been provided by the private sector and, technically, most GP practices are private partnerships. All the drugs, supplies and equipment used by the NHS are privately provided. Taken together this amounts to around 40% of the NHS budget. In addition some NHS organisations subcontract work to private providers. The NHS accounts for 2013/4 show that £10 billion of the total NHS budget of £113 billion was spent on care from non-NHS providers. The main growth in private provision has been in mental health and community health services'. (Wiki again !)As far as I am concerned I have paid high taxes for about 50 years which have helped provide excellent medical services and treatment 'free at the point of delivery'For that I am content and gratified.I am sure that I have put more into funding the health service than many with whom I shared a waiting room at George's yesterday - particularly those who were not English speaking !

John Hawkes ● 531d

The tube strike has now been called off following negotiations.The strike was called over the pay offer to all LU workers not just for tube drivers. I assume that those misrepresenting the strike action as being just for the benefit of drivers were unaware of this.Withdrawing labour is a fundamental right and the UK already have very strict legislation. Now there are some countries that have sensible strike laws but that requires a certain amount of independent arbitration - which the UK just doesn't seem to have.If you look at the pay review body the recommendations for nurses for example is ludicrous. The pay is below the level to recruit or retain sufficient staff with even the Conservative government ignoring it and awarding higher pay in previous years.Not only has many workers pay not kept pace with other countries expenditure on rent and utilities has increased.Junior doctors: The UK has a very low number of doctors when compared to other countries. This needs correcting. Let's not forget that many will be paying off student debt as well as being quite sort mainly in the Anglosphere."Junior doctors planning to leave UK cost taxpayers £2.8bn. Number of medics applying to work abroad jumped to a 10-year high in 2023." According to the Telegraph."TUBE UNION RMT announced today that London Underground workers will be taking rolling strike action in the new year after voting by over 90 per cent against a below inflation pay offer.RMT has made it clear that the latest pay offer of 5% from London Underground is unacceptable when Transport for London (TfL) has created a bonus pot of £13 million for senior managers and the commissioner took an 11 per cent pay rise in 2023 taking his salary up to £395,000."https://www.rmt.org.uk/news/tube-workers-to-take-strike-action-over-pay/

Ed Robinson ● 534d

Ms Bond'What has the Government done about doctors' pay ?They have negotiated with them and made a pay rise offer, that's what they have done.From the BBC News website - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-67626218'Junior doctors in England are to stage more strikes, in December and January, after rejecting a new pay offer put forward in talks with government.The British Medical Association (BMA) union said the proposal was worth an extra 3% on average this year. This is on top of an 8.8% rise already given.The strikes will be for three days from 07:00 on 20 December and six days from 07:00 on 3 January.The new-year walkout will be the longest in the NHS's history.It coincides with what is traditionally one of the NHS's busiest periods, with emergency services often under huge strain.The breakdown in talks comes after five weeks of negotiations during which industrial action had been suspended.The BMA wants a 35% pay uplift, to make up for what it says have been below-inflation rises since 2008'.You are correct, some people will turn to private health care - only to find they are then treated at a cost by NHS consultants and other staff !I very much doubt that there is a large community of medical staff that only do private work and do not also work and get paid by the NHS.I found this out when I googled my consultant and found that  top of his published CV was his private work at the hospital  where he was treating me !So you are right - 'the NHS is also having to prop up 'private' medicine'.

John Hawkes ● 534d

Mick Lynch, doubtless now back from his Easter break to which he, all his family and his nominated friends in all probability travelled by train at no cost (to them, not we taxpayers).So now he can get back to what he really enjoys - making life a misery for the travelling public, the majority of which earn far less than him and his members.Southfields tube was closed yesterday by the strike but they still had two 'workers' manning the access grill.I wonder how much they earned and whether it was overtime money.I do not have the greatest mobility and hence the use of buses yesterday was very difficult and painful.On Thursday I have a hospital appointment which I can get to by bus.But, will the doctors be at work to run the clinic ?And please don't give me all that guff about how poorly paid  hospital doctors are. (We of course know GPs can take home about  £100K per annum but then they are self-employed).Look up how much hospital doctors earn and it is not £15 an hour that the striking pickets in their silly orange beanies state.If you get the chance ask one of them what their last P60 looked like.Pretty good I would suspect with their shift allowances and generous tax payer funded pension contribution.And probably well within the the top percentile of salaries for the general working population as a whole.What is common between tube drivers and some doctors apart from avarice ?Both work for tax funded state organisations that the public depends on and both seem to be motivated by money with little recognition of the concept of 'public service'.Labour is making stupid and childish points about NHS waiting times.What do they expect if the staff strike so often ?Let's hope that if the Conservatives stay in power they will enact their new bill aimed at enforcing minimum service levels for the public sector during strikes.Under the proposals, some public sector workers would be required to work during a strike. The business secretary said the aim was to protect lives and livelihoods.But unions have threatened legal action if the bill is passed, saying it is "undemocratic, unworkable and illegal".Labour says they would repeal it if they win the next election.So at least one clear policy differentiation between the Parties !

John Hawkes ● 535d