Forum Topic

MattIf one were to analyse the increase in property values over the decades I'm sure there must be a number of factors; however, I would guess there are two, possibly three, primary factors: firstly, a rise following inflation over the period; secondly, rises differing geographically based on the supply and demand driven by scarcity of property and available income; that is further exacerbated in areas such as London with migration to it from other parts of the UK and Europe, plus many new builds of luxury flats perhaps only affordable by foreign investors or those with inflated city salaries and bonuses. If one wanted, I suspect one could buy a street of houses in Hull for the price of a large desirable house, or even luxury penthouse flat, in South West London. (I choose that example as I know a couple who moved to Hull because they were trapped into a miss-sold interest only mortgage and that was the only escape route.) I'd still say it comes down to a shortage of suitable accommodation, particularly of affordable social housing. In some areas I suspect the rental market may also be skewed by a large number of students;) landlords know they'll be there for a limited period. Most of us that purchased did so for security reasons when we were able to do so - the rental market in the UK seemed dire back in the 1970s, I spent several years sharing a grotty flat in Earl's Court with a number of ex college friends, before I purchased a flat in Putney. It also made sense financially to invest in paying a mortgage rather than rent a property.However, I do sympathise with younger people; when I was still at work I had to admit to younger colleagues I wouldn't be able to afford the house my wife and I purchased several years after I'd acquired my flat. I had ex colleagues who although on quite good IT salaries working in the City (although not in the trader, investment management, etc scale!) who when they started families move out to places such as Bicester, a two, three hour commute. (Although hybrid working help a lot, which many tech companies realised was necessary to attract good staff long before the pandemic.) I also know another young couple with a family who relocated to Bathgate (an Edinburgh suburb) because they could afford a four bedroom house there rather than a pokey flat in Surbiton.As Ivonne says it wasn't anything we intended and if one can't realise the value it's a paper gain which, as I noted in a previous post, can't easily be realised, plus, remember, any paper gain can potentially disappear overnight - although I agree scarce physical property it a lot safer than digital investments on the FTX exchange even with Truss-o-nomics trying to make mortgages unaffordable!I really don't know what the answer is other than a better supply of affordable and social housing, and possibly more remote working for those that can or more companies relocating from London and other expensive conurbations? Perhaps phasing in CGT on all properties would help, but in places like London where there's a shortage of property it might just get added to the prices …

Michael Ixer ● 1173d

I do not know who Resolution Foundation are and the "About us" tab was blank when I looked.The article is rather suspect, I am afraid.  "wealth windfall is unequal unearned and untaxed" is very skewed.  Unequal perhaps, because the increase in value is different according to the size of the property you own; not everybody owns properties to the value of £1/5/10/25m. But unearned and untaxed????  What do you think mortgage payments are?  The property you buy is subject to stamp duty based on the value of the property when it is purchased. Also, you pay Council tax based on the band the value of your property.Yes, property values have increased enormously but not everywhere.  I very much doubt properties in the north of England have gained as much as in the south.  There again, is it not supply and demand?  But above all it is value on paper as it does not materialize until you sell the property when capital gain taxes apply which, at the moment, range between 18 and 28% depending on the gain, not the value of the sale.So, unequal, unearned and untaxed is ridiculous.Price rises unfair to the younger generation?  Very.  But that is because all developers (and Councils) do is build luxury properties to be sold to wealthy foreign nationals.  I say this because of the enormous amount of properties sold to Russians, Asians, Greeks during the 2008 financial crisis (the latter triggered the Anti-tax avoidance directive in the EU that the ERG was so desperate to avoid!)But, affordable housing has just been a mouth piece.  Please, do not blame people who own their homes.  They are not speculators. 

Ivonne Holliday ● 1173d